Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

My Asymmetric Electrodynamic Machines

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • brian516
    replied
    Originally posted by Ufopolitics View Post
    Hello Brian516 and Welcome aboard,

    Don't worry about your previous confusion, it is not your fault.

    As you could see this guy is not there to help anyone, just to insist/push his "design" of single poles Imperial as "his own idea"...however, he is using ALL my CAD's and all my designs to run that thread.

    He has never wound any other motor than the Imperial he has been working on for over two years...

    Never has put together a small motor as the one you have.

    One of my first Diagrams here on post#96 written on 7/14/2012 was about a SINGLE COIL THREE POLE MOTOR and Diagram below:

    [IMG][/IMG]

    And as I wrote there, this type of winding is applicable to other configuration in bigger machines.

    But hey, let's talk about your five pole and forget about all 'counterfeit material'

    First do not listen to that guy about winding your motor with a HEAVIER GAUGE, pure nonsense, you use the SAME or FINER GAUGE and motor will run perfectly smooth and fine.

    The Imperial he is working on is originally wound with 16 awg and NOT with 18 awg like he is doing it right now...so, forgive him, he is full of it to the top of his head, and it does not allow him to think properly.

    About the Mechanical Set Up:

    To remove all epoxy resin and separate plastic fan, you will need a very sharp and fine blade and be very careful with fingers. try getting blade in between without damaging the epoxy on rotor metal.

    After fan out and all epoxy in slots, between poles taken out, you need to spread open each commutator hook, going from above to brake them apart to be able to pull wires out with a fine needle nose pliers, do it to both motors commutators. Do not apply heat with a soldering gun, as you may brake the comm copper elements from mica, then commutator is not good anymore.

    To pull one commutator out to use it on main motor you have to do it EVENLY FROM BELOW, meaning, DO NOT PUSH ONLY from one element or it will brake apart. Do not try to turn commutator while on shaft either, shaft has straight splines and you will brake it if forcing to turn it.

    This motors have enough room to add second commutator, but you may have to force shaft a bit up (towards shaft take off power), leaving less space at bottom of motor (back) enough to get shaft inside rear bushing...just measure distances.

    The other part to do is to 'elongate' or extrude the Main outer casing...where you may have to cut a ring off the end of second motor where brushes are mounted, it is all about doing the right measurements where to cut. At Main Motor you have to cut rear end to solder or glue the brush ring and use the housing and brushes from second motor. When you do all this cutting and soldering is better to remove magnets from casing. I have a 175 Watts Soldering Gun that could do that job easily. If you do not have that kind of gun, you could use epoxy or other glue compounds to 'weld' metal.

    Make sure before soldering the whole ring , tack it first and test freedom of shaft movement (not binding) by assembling the whole motor together with magnets and all brushes.

    When pressing the second commutator, make sure it is perfectly aligned to bottom one (the original that came with motor), meaning, aligning element to element in a linear fashion, as well as when you solder the casing ring, make sure it will hold brushes seating identical above and below.

    About the winding:

    Once you have all mechanical structures finished...the easier part is to wind it.

    The first winding on this Five Pole Motor was displayed here
    and CAD below:

    [IMG][/IMG]

    Here you could use different type of windings, including the Pentagon type or the 'Single Coil' unbelievable idea of this guy..., and I have all drawings to follow up the winding method of your choice.

    [IMG][/IMG]

    However, I recommend to wind the All North Type, where all coils (no matter if single or pairs) are wound all in same direction, like I have shown on the post I cited link above, on the three pole first motor I have shown here.

    Below is a video on a five pole where I test/compare the North-South Pairs versus the All North Pairs.

    [VIDEO]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=diY96XR76Fg[/VIDEO]


    Cheers and remember to be careful with blade.


    Good luck friend.


    Ufopolitics

    Hi there UFO and all,

    Sorry I didn't follow up directly after my last post and UFO's reply, I got a bit busy. Picked up an O-scope and had to clean it and get it functioning properly, and learn the basics of getting stable traces. I've never used a scope before, so it ate up all my time at first, but now I'm close to the point where I have a little more free time to spend on actual projects, too. I'm going to get started on my 5-pole build soon, but first I'm going to do a little more research into what type of windings I will go with. I'm just going to use the wire that I have available. The new wire that I have that is close to the factory size is 22awg, but for used, I have a decent variety. (just have to make sure I don't use any that has left-over epoxy stuck to it!)
    I'm open to suggestions for every aspect of this build.

    As for bonding the cases together, I could use JB weld, or, if my friend over at the machine shop isn't too busy, I could have him weld it for me. In that case, he has the proper tools available to get a perfectly straight cut on each case and get it aligned correctly for the weld.

    both shafts are a little bit short for my liking, and would leave very little room for me to use it as a prime mover for other projects later on, and also for any kind of testing, so I'm probably going to see if any of the local shops have SS rod of the correct size that I can grab. Usually they give me their small scraps for free, and bigger scraps for the price by weight of recycled metals.
    The other option I have would be to pull off some of the laminations and free up some more room on the shaft.

    Brian

    Leave a comment:


  • HuntingRoss
    replied
    SC#6 Schematic added and SC#7 3 coil 5 pole groups in Pairs 20 turns per coil commenced http://www.energeticforum.com/271717-post7384.html
    Last edited by HuntingRoss; 03-02-2015, 11:06 PM. Reason: Typo

    Leave a comment:


  • HuntingRoss
    replied
    Originally posted by YahwehisSpirit View Post
    i would also like to know if its a bad thing for the commutator to be between the magnets in the motor????
    It's unlikely to be bad as they're always in close proximity, but I would be surprised that there was sufficient room for that to happen.

    Happy Hunting

    mark

    Leave a comment:


  • YahwehisSpirit
    replied
    Originally posted by MagnaMoRo View Post
    Your welcome!

    Also, I had changed my original plan halfway into it from using 2 motors to make one. I decided instead to use 3 armatures, pushing 2 shafts until they meet in the middle armature. (I can only hope the middle armature laminates don't come apart under the vibration.)

    Instead of using the motor casings, I may try to build an open frame to hold the magnets, so you can see everything. My only issue is time.
    Im doing pretty much what you did but with two!! what kind of epoxy do you think i should use to insulate and bind the whole thing? while putting them together some of the armatures metal pices came off..... or do i need to at all?? i would also like to know if its a bad thing for the commutator to be between the magnets in the motor???? Here are some picks im just waiting on my commutators and my fiberfix ^_^
    Attached Files

    Leave a comment:


  • HuntingRoss
    replied
    Thank you UFO.

    Yes. SC#6 is 4 poles per coil / 3 coils per group. And the angle is certainly picking up some effect I can not explain. The output voltage is exceeding the input voltage at voltages above 10v. This is demonstrated in the higher wattage output driving an OEM 450w motor.

    My last 2 comm test on the Beast still couldn't out torque the OEM. I tried all sorts of permutations to no avail. But never say die...

    I have a few more mods on the SC model to enhance torque and output before it either proves itself or is abandoned. It has also been a useful learning platform.

    Happy Hunting

    mark

    Leave a comment:


  • Ufopolitics
    replied
    Sc7?

    Originally posted by HuntingRoss View Post
    OK.

    A question to those that have undeniably invested heavily in this thread.

    If my SC posts offend or detract from your work, please ask me to remove the SC work to my own thread.

    Obviously Midaz has excluded himself from the vote on the basis that he has an interest in his A1MoGen.

    Happy Hunting

    mark
    Hello Mark, hello to all,

    We exchanged pm's before related to your design, and I said it is OK to post it here, it is an interesting and different research end, that still does not move away completely from Asymmetry.

    I like the way you have set your output brushes related to rotation sense, which gives a wider angle to take induction and add it to the one carried/stored within coils from input.

    I would like you to do a future complete Asymmetric Model (2 comm) with Five Pole Coils...to test it against your SC6...or another one with Five Poles Coils Group...maybe a SC7?

    I believe your SC6 is 4 poles per coil right?

    Thanks for all you work Mark!


    Regards to All


    Ufopolitics

    Leave a comment:


  • HuntingRoss
    replied
    OK.

    A question to those that have undeniably invested heavily in this thread.

    If my SC posts offend or detract from your work, please ask me to remove the SC work to my own thread.

    Obviously Midaz has excluded himself from the vote on the basis that he has an interest in his A1MoGen.

    Happy Hunting

    mark

    Leave a comment:


  • Aaron
    replied
    your own thread

    Everyone is entitled to their opinion. However, if you don't like what is being shared in this thread and you have expressed this multiple times in no uncertain terms, there doesn't seem to be much point in continuing to post your disagreements here.

    You started another thread where you can state your case and anyone reading this thread is free to read it to see what direction you think motor design should go.



    Originally posted by Midaztouch
    Ross,

    You were advised by the group back in November on how Tesla's motors worked. I guess you thought that everyone, that had been working/studying for years, didn't know what they were talking about. So, what you have done is shown another way on how NOT to do it.... Just like you were told you LAST year!


    Since you want the spot light and your not a rookie anymore! Answer this...

    How do you compensate for the #1 Enemy, "HEAT" in the Single Commutator Design?
    And you can't throw more money at it and/or make a already weak motor, weaker.


    Stong MIDAZ Brand Black Coffee for you Ross... Wake up!

    Keep it Clean and Green
    Midaz

    1 + 1 = 2... Not 11

    Leave a comment:


  • HuntingRoss
    replied
    Added static scooter test, output load tests and a photo of the build http://www.energeticforum.com/271717-post7384.html

    Leave a comment:


  • HuntingRoss
    replied
    Further test results added http://www.energeticforum.com/271717-post7384.html

    Leave a comment:


  • HuntingRoss
    replied
    SC#6 Build and Test Results

    SC#6 Build and Test Results added to http://www.energeticforum.com/271717-post7384.html

    Leave a comment:


  • MagnaMoRo
    replied
    3 into 1

    Originally posted by YahwehisSpirit View Post
    Heck yeah thankyou!! Im waiting on my fiber fix now and i ordered a few commutators!! Im also pushing the shaft into the stator half way and another shaft in the other side of the stator so ill have two shafts in there its so long im thinking about using both stators to make one long motor from two. im cutting the end off both casings and joining them with the fiber fix. Im thinking about hooking the batterys that will run the motor up to a bedini motor so i get it perpetual. I was thinking the output on the asym motor will act like the main batt on the bedini and the charging batt can be the batt used...???
    Your welcome!

    Also, I had changed my original plan halfway into it from using 2 motors to make one. I decided instead to use 3 armatures, pushing 2 shafts until they meet in the middle armature. (I can only hope the middle armature laminates don't come apart under the vibration.)

    Instead of using the motor casings, I may try to build an open frame to hold the magnets, so you can see everything. My only issue is time.
    Attached Files

    Leave a comment:


  • YahwehisSpirit
    replied
    Thankyou

    Originally posted by MagnaMoRo View Post
    I used FiberFix to bond the two motor halves. I got it at Meijer, in the glue department. Very strong. Just cut to size, dip in water and wrap your part. Hardens like epoxi. Can be sanded. Look up my posted pics.

    MagnaMoRo
    Heck yeah thankyou!! Im waiting on my fiber fix now and i ordered a few commutators!! Im also pushing the shaft into the stator half way and another shaft in the other side of the stator so ill have two shafts in there its so long im thinking about using both stators to make one long motor from two. im cutting the end off both casings and joining them with the fiber fix. Im thinking about hooking the batterys that will run the motor up to a bedini motor so i get it perpetual. I was thinking the output on the asym motor will act like the main batt on the bedini and the charging batt can be the batt used...???

    Leave a comment:


  • Midaztouch
    replied
    [IMG][/IMG]

    Ross

    I don't like the group winds, at all... but Raul is right, this diagram above is the best that you can get with group topology/group-pair wind spacing for you motor.

    Here is some food for thought:

    1.) The group pair coil wire length is very long. What was your voltage drop %?

    2.) 60% of your group coils' magnetic strength is at weakest points of the North & South stators' fields and zero/0 torque. The strongest coil force being marked at the Dark Blue #(1).

    3.) Your RPMs will be sky high during NO LOAD! The price for custom gearing has to be $$$$ for a small project... (I looked at gearing price$ for my 28pole 20kg A1Mo-Gen electric motorcycle project last week. The A1Mo-Gen has 4900 RPMs @ 36v during No LOAD. http://www.energeticforum.com/renewa...reactor-2.html) The gearing & chain was still real money for high torque motors.
    Even thou a project is fun.... In your honest opinion, Is it cost effective to buy custom gearing for a small project?!

    4.) Splitting the groups into "groups pairs" further weakens the torque of Raul's previous 2 commutator group wind design/topology above 30%... What is/are the benifit(s) of the Single commutator/SC over Tesla's 2 commutator patent??

    Keep it Clean and Green
    Midaz

    Common sense & Observation is the foundation of science!
    1 + 1 = 2... Not 11
    Last edited by Midaztouch; 02-28-2015, 11:06 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • HuntingRoss
    replied
    Hi UFO

    Thank you for the schematics...and yes, the OEM is 5 pole coils @ 0.53mm wire.

    When I consolidated in my mind what I was attempting with this embodiment I looked at the 4 and 5 pole options. I decided on the 3 pole option because it placed the P1C1 bisector closest to the magnet bisector, I also thought it would limit the revs of the machine...but if it has had that effect it still revs like a dervish on steroids.

    I've now taken delivery of 2 extra motors so I can chop 2 at the same and compare them. Working with one hasn't been too much of a problem but my builds are converging on the OEM torque so it's helpful to springboard from this design before trashing it.

    I have also taken delivery of a 12.5" mini moto dirt bike rear wheel assembly and am ordering a custom 135 tooth laser cut #25 sprocket to test the output by converting revs to torque. A rough knock up on the kitchen table last night confirms my calculations and turned the wheel at 160 rpm @ 10v. Once I have a proper rig for this I will torque test and report back.

    Tomorrow should see one of the new motors chopped and wired for 4 or 5 poles...I too was thinking 5 poles might extend the attraction coil too close to the cog point and turn my motor into a heat source. I will check and see how it looks on paper first.

    I must say for wood-be builders embarking on this adventure the SC model is an extremely easy build. There is no need to try and prise delicate parts and weld bodies or achieve perfect alignments. Whilst I accept it is a departure from the asymm model, as a hybrid it gives good torque, excellent revs and useful power at the output leads.

    Happy Hunting

    mark

    Leave a comment:

Working...
X