What I have been doing is somewhat different to mats work and I don't really want to comment on that because what he did and what I am doing is very different.
If you have four coils setup like mats drawing, you don't have to worry about coil shorting.
I never put a diode on the armature as I did not find it necessary but again my setup is very different.
Going back to your scope shots, the lower image shows a regular small drop in voltage, I would assume that this is when the brushes connect with the segments. All the transients that you see are likely caused by interactions between the coils as they connect and disconnect. As I have said before there are many complex interactions between the coils on an armature.These coils, I assume, are not interconnected so as one coil connects or disconnects from the supply the transient will also appear in the other coils.
Much of what I am about to say is pure guesswork so there is no guarantee that this is correct.
If there are recovery brushes connected to the other coils, this transient can be collected there. If a diode is in the recovery circuit then the transient can be collected in one direction but not in the other. The transient that is not collected will appear in all the other coils.
Not sure about the terminology but I will call it a reflected transient. This is momentarily stored voltage which will discharge when it gets the chance and maybe this is what you are seeing. The reason that they are not regular in their timing may be because of small differences in the commutator/brush arrangement.
I say this because there appears to be four different sizes of transient which would fit in with four coils.
Normally we do not see a transient as we connect the power but through a transformer action in the coils it may become visible. Maybe this is the reason for both positive and negative transients.
As I have said in my motors I do not have diodes and I get a build up of voltage in the armature. Hiwater has experienced a lot of arcing on his commutator suggesting very big voltages.
The motors we are using are actually delco remy generators or similar. They have field coils and not magnets. The transformer actions are very complex. They are motors that have little BEMF in the motor field coils but these coils cause no torque. The torque and BEMF appears in the generator coils which are in the same housing. The motor accelerates under load because of transformer action.
I suppose you cannot call them motors as they are rotary transformers. We should not use the term "motor field coil" we should use the term "energizer coil" the generator field coils are also the secondaries on the transformer.
The attached image should give you a clue as to what I am doing
If you have four coils setup like mats drawing, you don't have to worry about coil shorting.
I never put a diode on the armature as I did not find it necessary but again my setup is very different.
Going back to your scope shots, the lower image shows a regular small drop in voltage, I would assume that this is when the brushes connect with the segments. All the transients that you see are likely caused by interactions between the coils as they connect and disconnect. As I have said before there are many complex interactions between the coils on an armature.These coils, I assume, are not interconnected so as one coil connects or disconnects from the supply the transient will also appear in the other coils.
Much of what I am about to say is pure guesswork so there is no guarantee that this is correct.
If there are recovery brushes connected to the other coils, this transient can be collected there. If a diode is in the recovery circuit then the transient can be collected in one direction but not in the other. The transient that is not collected will appear in all the other coils.
Not sure about the terminology but I will call it a reflected transient. This is momentarily stored voltage which will discharge when it gets the chance and maybe this is what you are seeing. The reason that they are not regular in their timing may be because of small differences in the commutator/brush arrangement.
I say this because there appears to be four different sizes of transient which would fit in with four coils.
Normally we do not see a transient as we connect the power but through a transformer action in the coils it may become visible. Maybe this is the reason for both positive and negative transients.
As I have said in my motors I do not have diodes and I get a build up of voltage in the armature. Hiwater has experienced a lot of arcing on his commutator suggesting very big voltages.
The motors we are using are actually delco remy generators or similar. They have field coils and not magnets. The transformer actions are very complex. They are motors that have little BEMF in the motor field coils but these coils cause no torque. The torque and BEMF appears in the generator coils which are in the same housing. The motor accelerates under load because of transformer action.
I suppose you cannot call them motors as they are rotary transformers. We should not use the term "motor field coil" we should use the term "energizer coil" the generator field coils are also the secondaries on the transformer.
The attached image should give you a clue as to what I am doing
Comment