Originally posted by Farrah Day
View Post
And ions are a charge exchange medium!
Now I can't say with 100% certainty that there is no difference, cause there is. Ions are not the same things as electrons, but as far as I am aware the currents normally going trough the fluid occur for 99.99% because of ions in the water, since pure water is not a good conductor. And as far as I remember this can happen, because these ions become nutralized at one plate by either taking or releasing an electron. And these subsequently become charged again, because they either react with f.e. H+ or OH- ions, or they drift to the other plate.
So, all things considered, I think there is not much of a difference at all. And given that both Meyer and Puharich claimed they were able to produce gas without current, most likely along the way I explained, I think there is a really fair chance this way of thinking is indeed correct.
And remember: H+ and OH- ions aren't the only ions in the fluid when you add an electrolyte! You do add that to be able to drive a current trough your water, and Puharich gives pretty good numbers about what would be the best concentration of salts in your water....
Comment